Churchill's brother quizzed over passport irregularity

Churchill's brother quizzed over passport irregularity

Preetu Nair, TNN

PANAJI: Seabra Alemao, 57, younger brother of PWD minister Churchill Alemao has been asked to clarify regarding his and his father's name by the passport office at Panaji, as they differ from those given in the birth certificate.

He will also have to pay a fine amounting to Rs 5,000 for suppressing personal particulars. A report regarding the same has been sent to the ministry of external affairs, New Delhi.

A letter dated April 22, 2009 asks Seabra to explain "regarding passport application in 2004 and correct name as per old application." While in his passport application dated December 16, 2008, Seabra has written his name as "Presentacao Seabra Joaquim Alemao", the birth certificate has his name as "Presentacao Seabra Joaquim Cerejeira Sacrafamilia Alemao". Similarly with his father's name, in the passport application Seabra has written it as "Antonio Augusto Braz Clemente Alemao", while the birth certificate states "Antonio Augusto Braz Clemente Fortunato Flosculo Mario Ragario Piedade Alemao".

Passport officer S B Hire refused to comment. However, officials at the passport office said, "On April 15, we got a positive recommendation for Seabra from the police. He is now eligible to get the passport after clarifying his and his father's name and after paying the fine amount."

When contacted, Seabra said, "I have given an affidavit to the passport office in which I have clearly mentioned my full name and my father's full name. They have not sent me a letter asking me to pay any fine."

The disparities came to light when the passport office conducted an inquiry into Seabra's application after receiving a police report on January 16, 2009, that instead of approving or rejecting the passport application stated, "discretion of passport officer".

The report came from the DySP CID/SB, despite the fact that the Colva police inspector's report states that there are no court cases pending against Seabra and he has been acquitted in two cases and he can be issued a passport.

After receiving the police report, passport officials conducted an inquiry into Seabra's application and found that he had first applied for a passport in 2004, in which he had given his and father's name as per the birth certificate. However, his file was closed on December 30, 2004, as he failed to respond to queries raised by the passport office. At that time in the column for passport details, Seabra had said, "not known" and the passport office had sought a clarification regarding this, which Seabra had failed to provide.

Later, on December 16, 2008 Seabra filed a fresh passport application. "He failed to mention that he had applied for and was not issued a passport in 2004. On seeking a clarification, Seabra submitted a notarized affidavit on February 17, 2009 stating that he had previously applied for a passport. Seabra will have to shell out another Rs 1,000 for not informing the passport office that he had previously applied for a passport," officials said.

"In 2004 I had applied for the passport but had lost the form number and the passport office had said they could not trace the form so I made a fresh application in 2008," said Seabra.

On Thursday, Churchill had addressed a press conference at which he had alleged that the passport officer refused to renew his brother Seabra's passport on the grounds that criminal cases were pending against him, in spite of the fact that the sessions court had cleared him of all charges. However, passport officials denied these allegations.

Seabra, however, made the same allegations on Friday and said, "They are denying me the passport, saying there a cases pending against me, though I have submitted court orders acquitting me."

2 May 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition