Chemists fume over GMC drug store tender

Chemists fume over GMC drug store tender
Preetu Nair, TNN


PANAJI: Changes in the eligibility criteria for running a pharmacy
at the Goa Medical College and Hospital
and Yatri Niwas have come under a
cloud.

Unlike in the past, when the GMC pharmacy operation was open to manufacturers, retailers and wholesalers, this time the latter two are deemed not eligible.

The tender has been drafted in such a manner that only a Goa registered drug manufacturer, having its own manufacturing unit and retail outlets, besides manufacturing products for more than five reputed large pharma companies and with over five years manufacturing experience can bid for it. This has not only got chemists in Goa fuming, but has narrowed the eligibility field to just two manufacturers.

A letter from the Chemists and Druggists Association, Goa, to health minister Vishwajit Rane said, “We are pained to note that none of our members are eligible to even quote for the pharmacy as the clause includes only the manufacturing companies.”

“We have requested the health minister to reconsider the eligibility criteria by removing the ‘manufacturing company clause’ and allowing individuals having a pharmacy business to quote,” Ratnadeep Kurtarkar, the association president told TOI.

Rane citing price considerations is unwilling to change the specifications. “We want to encourage the small scale pharma industry that will give us a better price. I am not interested in entertaining traders. We want a corporate company with retail experience, who can maintain a minimum level of drugs, materials and surgical appliances at the pharmacy, so that indenting by the GMC can be done from here if the product is not available in the hospital,” said Rane.

President of Chemists and Druggists Association, Goa, Ratnadeep Kurtarkar, however, does not appear convinced by health minister Vishwajit Rane’s explanation that the move to exclude retailers is aimed at encouraging small scale pharma industry.

He said traders do maintain a minimum inventory of drugs and surgical appliances in the pharmacy.

“If by adhering to the Central government’s policy to give cheaper medicines, the state government is proposing a ‘Janaushadhi’ store at GMC, then a manufacturer would be able to manufacture generic drugs and give it to patients at cheaper rates. But a retailer or any manufacturer selling branded drugs will have to sell them at the MRP,” added Kurtarkar.

The tender’s new criteria allows just two companies to bid for the contract. “Only two companies meet the requirements. One is the Hede Group run Shwarde Pharmaceutical Pvt Ltd at Corlim that has a retail shop at Porvorim and Goa Antibiotics and Pharmaceuticals Limited (GAPL) which has a retail shop at GMC,” sources at Food and Drug Administration told TOI.

Confirming this, Goa pharmaceutical manufacturers association president Dilip Salgaonkar said, “There are three or four pharma companies registered in Goa. To the best of my knowledge only two pharma companies — GAPL and Shwarde — have retail shopping also.”

There is a further catch in the eligibility criteria, which states that the pharma company should be registered as a small scale industry. “GAPL doesn’t have SSI registration. It has medium scale registration with government of India,” Goa State Industries Association executive secretary GP Chimulkar told TOI.

Rane explained saying, “We have shortlisted two companies — Hede group’s pharma company and government run GAPL. We are in the process of verifying if GAPL is registered under the Small Scale Industries (SSI). If so registered, GAPL will get the contract, otherwise it will go to the Hede group.”

2 May 2009,The Times of India, Goa edition