CBI to return Scarlett’s organs

CBI to return Scarlett’s organs
Preetu Nair | TNN

Panaji: The Central Bureau of Investigation, which is inquiring into the rape and murder of British teenager Scarlett Keeling, has agreed to hand over the girl’s organs to her mother Fiona Mackeown on receipt of the chemical examination reports.
The reports are awaited from the Central Forensic Science Laboratory and All India Institute of Medical Sciences, New Delhi.
In a letter to the British high commissioner to India, Sir Charles Richard Vernon Stagg, on October 14, 2008, CBI joint director (policy) Sudhir Saxena, said, “The reports from both AIIMS and CFSL New Delhi are awaited.”

Decent burial only after organs are received: Fiona
Panaji: The Central Bureau of Investigation has decided to hand over the organs of British teenager Scarlett Keeling, who was raped and murdered in Goa, to her mother Fiona Mackeown on receipt of the chemical examination reports.
CBI joint director (policy) Sudhir Saxena, in a letter to British high commissioner to India Sir Charles Richard Vernon Stagg, on October 14, 2008, said, “On receipt of the report and the organs — pieces of both lungs, pieces of liver and half of uterus — can be handed over to Fiona Mackeown after obtaining permission from the children’s court, Panaji.”
Speaking to TOI over the phone from her home in Devon, UK, Fiona, who had written to the CBI seeking Scarlett’s organs, said, “The CBI has said that some of the organs have been destroyed, but they would hand over the remaining organs of my daughter soon. Once we receive the organs, we can give her a decent burial.”
Scarlett’s body had been found on February 19, 2008 at Anjuna beach, and a case of rape and murder was registered. Fiona had taken her daughter’s body to the UK for a third autopsy after two forensic autopsies at the Goa Medical College and Hospital. The autopsy at the coroner’s court in Devon had revealed that Scarlett’s kidneys, stomach and uterus were missing. Doctors at GMC’s forensic department had stated that the organs had been preserved for tests.
While Scarlett’s liver and pieces of her lungs were deposited in a sealed envelope by the Goa police with the children’s court, half of the uterus and slides containing tissues were collected from the Goa Medical College and Hospital by the CBI for examination.
The letter to the high commissioner was in response to queries raised by the former in a meeting with CBI officials in Delhi on September 3, 2008. During the meeting, the high commissioner had sought information regarding investigations into the case, especially the return of the organs.
The CBI letter added that following procedure, the remaining biological materials (organs) utilized by the Forensic Science Laboratory, Mumbai, for chemical analysis were preserved for a period of three weeks and thereafter destroyed as per the existing protocol, it being “hazardous” to preserve them.

November 3,2008, The Times of India, Goa edition

Goa;German girl submits to medical test

German girl submits to medical test
Doctors Non-Commital On Rape
TIMES NEWS NETWORK

Panaji: Almost a month after a German woman lodged a police complaint against education minister Atanasio Monserrate’s son Rohit alleging sexual abuse and rape of her minor daughter, the girl submitted herself to a medical examination on Sunday morning.
Highly-placed sources confirmed that the medical examination conducted at Goa Medical College and Hospital by a three-member panel of a lady gynaecologist and two forensic doctors confirmed an “old hymen tear”, but refrained from forming any opinion regarding “recent sexual intercourse” after an almost two-hour regular examination. They have, however, preserved vaginal swabs and other materials for serological examination.
Sources said that an ultrasound test to check if the girl was pregnant or had undergone an abortion or a miscarriage did not reveal anything. The examination was conducted after the girl gave her consent.
Ever since her mother lodged a police complaint on October 2, the girl had been refusing to give her statement or to subject herself to a medical test, and the two had often fought over this. However, the girl deposed before a local court on Saturday afternoon before undergoing the medical test on Sunday.
After the medical examination, the German mother’s counsel Aires Rodrigues claimed that the doctors told him that the girl had been raped. “They have performed all the tests, including ultrasound of the uterus. She may even go for an HIV test.”
Apart from charging Rohit with the rape of her 14-yearold daughter, the German mother had accused Warren Alemao, nephew of PWD minister Churchill Alemao, of sexually abusing the minor.
Police sources said the mother had agreed to allow a test on her daughter to check for HIV and STD, but she later withdrew the permission alleging a twohour delay on the part of the hospital authorities as “part of a larger conspiracy”.

Rohit will cooperate,says Babush

Panaji: Education minister Atanasio “Babush” Monserrate announced on Sunday that the police have recorded the statement of his son Rohit, who has been accused of raping a minor German girl.
Stating that the law should follow its own course, Babush said in a press statement, “The truth should be revealed without fear or favour. The German girl had refused to depose or get herself medically examined up to November 1, 2008, almost a month after her mother complained of the alleged rape. Now that she has given her statement and offered herself for medical examination, Rohit will cooperate with the police in their investigation.”
Apart from Rohit, the police have recorded the statement of his wife Jennifer also, amongst others, he said in the statement faxed to newspaper offices.
“I believe that my son Rohit, an adult, should be responsible for his acts and must face the consequences of breaking the law if he has done so. But in accordance with law, I shall resist attempts from certain quarters to selectively target only my family members for extraneous and political purposes,” added Babush.

Police to study medical report

Panaji: The German minor girl, whose mother has charged education minister Atanasio Monserrate’s son Rohit of sexually abusing and raping her daughter, underwent medical examination at the Goa Medical College and Hospital on Sunday morning. A three-member team of doctors conducted tests on the minor.
Police confirmed receipt of the medical report but refused to divulge any details.
SP (North) Bosco George said, “We will have to study the medical examination report and the statement of the girl to determine the further course of action.”
E a rl i e r, a c c o m p a - nied by her mother and lawyer, the girl in blue skirt and top arrived at the forensic department of GMC at 11 am on Sunday and had to wait for almost 40 minutes before the tests could be performed.

November 3,2008, The Times of India, Goa edition