They didn’t really need a reason to torture her

They didn’t really need a reason to torture her
Preetu Nair, TNN

PANAJI: The first time she was “burnt” was for not doing the dishes. But the sad part is that there was no work to be done, all the dishes had
already been cleaned.

This is what a ten-year-old maid tortured by her employer has told the police. In her statement, the girl has also said that she was often beaten up or kicked in the stomach.

The girl, who incidentally belongs to a scheduled tribe, was also taunted about this. And now her alleged tormentors—Porvorim resident Audumber (Shubham) Pednekar, a civil engineer, his wife Minaxi and sister-in-law Tina—face charges under the Prevention of Atrocities (SC/ST) Act apart from charges under the IPC and the Goa Children’s Act.

While Audumber was arrested and later freed on bail, Minaxi and Tina are absconding.

Sources said the minor, who lost her father last year, was originally from Gadag, Hubli, but was living with her grandmother in Goa. About seven months back, a neighbour approached her grandmother and brought her to the Pednekar residence to work as a domestic help.

“She told us that initially the family was fine and she was asked to do all the work. The torture started a month later, when Tina allegedly started hitting her with a wire for not cleaning utensils or not mopping the floor or for failing to wash clothes on time.”

The girl would then be forced to sleep in the balcony. Her employers would lock the door from inside and open it only in the morning, sources said.

According to the victim, she was first “burnt” for not washing utensils even when there was no utensil in the sink to wash. “The girl said that Tina took a hot spoon from a stove and put it to her face,” sources said.

The girl was once allegedly kicked on the stomach by Audumber for failing to remove a stain on his trousers. “When she fell on a stone slab in the bathroom (used for washing clothes), she was further beaten with a pipe from the washing machine,” say police sources.

The final straw, the police said, was when the girl drank the couple’s seven-month-old twins’ medicine. “I was feeling very sick (with fever) and still had to do the work. As they were not giving me any medicine I took the children’s medicine,” the girl told the police.

When Minaxi learnt of this, she told the minor that she would have to burn her. The girl said that Minaxi then closed the door and windows to ensure that no one heard the girl’s screams and placed a heated flat steel spoon on her leg, back and hand, leaving burns and blisters, police said.

Even as the girl—without medical attention—writhed in pain for days, the family forced her to work. On Saturday, when Minaxi was feeding the babies and Tina had gone to the bathroom, the girl ran away.

“Since the girl is from a scheduled tribe, we have added Section 3 (1) (11) of Prevention of Atrocities (SC/ST) Act, besides sections of the IPC and Children’s Act against the three accused. Investigations have been transferred to DySP Gundu Naik,” said police spokesperson SP A V Deshpande.

Meanwhile, the girl, who had suffered burn injuries on her back and thighs, is recuperating at Goa Medical College and Hospital.

GMC doctors on Monday said she had suffered “simple injuries”, but didn’t specify the amount of injuries on her body.

Unhappy with this, the police have written to the GMC dean requesting a complete medical examination. “The dean has constituted a medical board that will examine the girl on Wednesday for all possible injuries, both old and new,” added Deshpande.

Pednekar’s advocate Damodar Dhond said, “The girl’s medical certificate has opined that she has simple injuries. This is not a serious offence. I am not aware that a new section has been added. We have filed for anticipatory bail for the two women and will wait for the reply from the police,” he said.

“We will oppose the anticipatory bail application of the two co-accused. We are also going to file a revision application against the bail granted to Pednekar,” said Deshpande.

29 July 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Soiled sheets, torn gown greet minor

Soiled sheets, torn gown greet minor
Preetu Nair, TNN

PANAJI: The ugly side of Goa Medical College and Hospital was once again exposed when the ten-year-old victim of child abuse was admitted on
Saturday. She was given soiled sheets and a torn gown to wear, until members of the Goa State Commission for Protection of Child Rights intervened on Monday.

GSCPCR chairperson Sameera Kazi said, “When we visited the girl in hospital on Monday, we saw that she had been given a soiled bedsheet and a dirty and torn gown to wear. We directed the nurse to take care of the minor and change the soiled clothes, which they did after some initial reluctance.”

According to sources, the girl spent the forst night in the soiled clothes in which she was brought to hospital by the police. It was only on Sunday that she was given a dirty and torn gown at GMC.

Incidentally, health minister Vishwajit Rane has often stressed that adequate arrangements should be made to ensure that patients are not given soiled sheets or torn gowns.

Reacting to the treatment meted out to the child, Rane said, “I am shocked. I am told by the joint director accounts that 6,000 plus bed sheets have been sent to GMC on Monday. I will look into the matter.”

When contacted, GMC medical superintendent Dr Rajan Kunkolienkar said, “I have personally ensured that she is given the best care possible. To provide better care and ensure that visitors don’t disturb her, we are shifting her to a private room.”

Sources said that when at first Kazi confronted the room nurse about the soiled sheets, the duty nurse insisted that the sheets were changed regularly. But the child revealed that it had not been changed since the time she had been brought to the hospital.

Kazi told TOI, “We were told that the staff was applying medicine on her. But when I opened the silver tube, we found that the seal had not been broken.” Interestingly, the doctor treating the minor has asked NGO Scan to purchase the silver
X tube and an injection as the same was not available in the hospital.

The GSCPCR recorded the girl’s statement on Tuesday evening and will conduct a separate inquiry in the incident of child abuse.

29 July, 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition