Mumbai hospital turns away patients

Mumbai hospital turns away patients
Preetu Nair | TNN

Panaji: After three months of treatment at Goa Medical College and hospital (GMC) produced no result, two and half year old Vibhav Borkar from Borim, Ponda was advised a biopsy. The biopsy report revealed non-Hodgkin’s lymphoma (cancer).
Armed with a certificate from GMC dated June 12, 2008, advising oncology, ‘facilities for which are available neither at GMC nor elsewhere in the state of Goa’, Vibhav’s parents, accompanied by an attendant, travelled by air as advised by GMC to Mumbai’s Tata Memorial hospital (TMH) on June 13, 2008.
But on reaching the Mumbai hospital, they were refused admission by TMH for want of beds. “They asked us to return after four days. But my son’s condition was bad and the doctor’s in Goa had said that he needed immediate medical attention,” said Viraj Borkar the child’s father.
TMH director Dr K P Dinshaw says, “We always have a problem of beds. But sooner or later, the child would have been admitted in the hospital.”
Vibhav was admitted to another private hospital in Mumbai, in the hope that the Goa government might help save their only son’s life. But the directorate of health services in Goa refused to bear the expenses. “They refused to help stating that the private hospital is not recognised by the Goa government for its mediclaim scheme,” said Viraj.
“The treatment costs Rs four lakh and we have already spent Rs one lakh. We have no more money to spend,” said the aggrieved father, who works as a clerk in a private engineering college in the state.
Though Vibhav has received initial treatment, he needs chemotherapy followed by radiotherapy for 8 to 10 months, that might cost Rs four lakh, the parents said.
Health Services director Dr Rajnanda Dessai said, “The family can submit the bills to us and we will refer the matter to the government. If the government agrees, we will pay them.”
Cancer continues to be a major ailment in Goa and even toddlers are not spared. Every year, at the GMC alone, about 45 to 50 children are detected with cancer. The biggest irony is that even though the state government claims that it is concerned with the rising cancer cases in the state and has sent a proposal to the Union health ministry for setting up a regional cancer centre in Goa, Goa doesn’t have a medical oncologist to take care of cancer patients.
“At present most cancer cases are referred to Tata Memorial for preliminary treatment and followed up at GMC as Goa doesn’t have a medical oncologist,” said a GMC doctor, on condition of anonymity.

July 4, 2008, The Times of India, Goa edition