Tuesday, August 18, 2009

'He may paint Ganesha as Michael Jackson next'


'He may paint Ganesha as Michael Jackson next'
Preetu Nair, TNN



Panaji: The police have warned artist Subodh Kerkar to be wary of hurting religious sentiments after Hindu Janjagruti Samithi (HJS) complained about his paintings of Lord Ganesha.

According to sources, acting on the HJS complaint , the police have sent a report to the sub-divisional magistrate explaining the circumstances of the case and the law and order problem that could arise out of it. The complaint has also been referred to the prosecution director for legal opinion.

Legal eagles were divided on the issue. While senior counsel Surendra Dessai accused the police of being lenient on the artist, advocate Arun Bras de Sa asked, " the question is under what provisions of the law are the police prohibiting the artist from having the exhibition? If it is a work of art, then the perception may differ."

According to Dessai, the police could have booked the artist under section 295 (A) of IPC, which is a cognizable offence, for hurting religious feelings, " on the contrary , the police have given him a light treatment by issuing notice under section 149, probably to balance the freedom of art and penal action," he said.

Section 295 (A) of IPC deals with deliberate and malicious acts, intended to outrage religious feelings of any class by insulting its religion or religious beleifs which could be either by words, spoken or written, or by signs or by visible representations.

Advocate de Sa said, "section 149 of the CrPC under which the notice has been served does not speak of religious insult. It deals with a police officer preventing the commission of any cognizable offence. The question if under what provisions of law are the police prohibiting the artist from having exhibition? If it is a work of art , then the perception may differ."

Referring to a recent Supreme Court judgment, in the case of M.F.Hussain where it was alleged the he had offended Hindus with a painting representing Bharat Mata as a nude goddess, de Sa said, "the Supreme Court opined that legal proceedings against the painter should be dropped and said that the nudity potrayed by Hussain had a long history. The judgment said,'there are many such pictures, paintings and sculptures and some of them are in temples'.

Speaking to TOI, HJS state convenor, Jayesh Thali said, "Artistic freedom should not be at the cost of hurting public sentiment and gain publicity. If painting Lord Ganesh as sumo wrestler is allowed, then tommorow the artist may paint Ganesh in the form of Michael Jackson or Madonna. If the artist is really secular, he should also draw such pictures of Christ during Christmas and Mohammed Paigambar during Id."

ART VIEW

"We should have certain limits for freedom. Freedom does not mean going out of the line. To depict what we want, we need to do it with a sense of responsibility. Being a Catholic, my feeling were hurt when i looked at the pictures (of Ganesha) as they were hurting the God i respect. The police is justified in giving the notice this time for the sake of keeping peace and communal harmony"

Yolanda D' Souza/ Artist

"It is quite unfortunate that the state is getting involved in matters of art. If they have to be involved, they should be involved in facilitating discussions between the artist and the powers that oppose a creation of art"

Abhay Sardesai/ Editor, Art India


"I have seen Subodh Kerkar's works and they are beautiful. If you go to some of the temples in India, you will see the same type of work. There is nothing wrong with what he has done"

Norman Tagore/ Artist

"Artist need freedom to express themselves. At the same time , they should impose self - restraint. If there is law which deters an artist from doing such a thing then the police can intervene to ensure that there is no law and order problem."

Naguesh Sardesai / Artist

Goa Police bow to pressure, ask Kerkar to stop show

Goa Police bow to pressure, ask Kerkar to stop show
Preetu Nair, TNN
PANAJI: Cowing under pressure from the Hindu Janjagruti Samiti (HJS), the police on Monday served notice on reputed Goan artist Subodh Kerkar to “desist from getting involved in such activities which may insult religious feelings or religious beliefs”. SP (North) Bosco George said Kerkar “should keep in mind the sentiments of the community and avoid creating a law and order problem”. “We will soon take a decision on whether or not the artist’s graphics hurt sentiments.

If it is found to hurt religious sentiments, we will initiate legal action against him,” he said. HJS had petitioned the police last week alleging that Kerkar had published “drawings of Lord Ganesh in various positions”, thereby insulting religious beliefs. It also wanted that the artist’s exhibition of Ganesha drawings be stopped. Earlier this month, HJS had demanded that the Goa State Museum remove M F Husain’s ‘Standing Buddha’ from its gallery. Officials said the matter would be taken up with higher authorities.

Even as the Calangute police issued notice to Kerkar under section 149 CrPC (police powers to prevent cognizable offence), the artist said he would go ahead with his exhibition. He also sought police protection apprehending that some organisations might try to disrupt his show scheduled from August 20 to 31, 2009 at the Kerkar Art Gallery in Calangute. Kerkar also alleged that on Monday he received calls from unknown persons, abusing him and threatening to murder him.

On receiving his complaint, the police have registered an offence under section 507 IPC (criminal intimidation by an anonymous communication) against unknown persons. “There is absolutely no intention of hurting anybody’s religious feelings. My drawings are my offerings to Shri Ganapati and no kind of insult is intended,” he said. “If some people’s feelings have been hurt by these drawings, it only shows their narrow-mindedness and fanaticism.

May Lord Ganesh help them clear their minds,” he said. “You (police) are most welcome to my gallery any time to view my drawings and judge for yourself,” Kerkar said in his reply to the police.

18 August 2009,The Times of India, Goa edition

Monday, August 17, 2009

Chinks in Goa swine flu plan exposed

Chinks in Goa swine flu plan exposed
Preetu Nair

PANAJI: Neither of the two Rapid Response Teams (RRT) - consisting of an epidemiologist and microbiologist each - were present at Chicalim cottage hospital from Saturday afternoon till late Sunday evening and there’s no night screening happening at the Dhargalim border.

This at a time when health officials say that 50 to 60 patients queue up at the Chicalim cottage hospital for testing and the number of suspected swine flu cases is rising daily.

On Saturday afternoon, Malcolm Coelho, 27, who had arrived in Goa from Mumbai went for swine flu test at Chicalim, where he found neither RRT present. Speaking to TOI from his home in Cuncolim on Sunday, Coelho, a businessman said, “On Friday night, I developed temperature, body ache, diarrhoea, cough and sore throat.

As I had influenza symptoms, I was immediately taken to Cottage hospital, Chicalim. Here, government nurses refused to attend to me, stating ‘The doctors left at 2 pm. It is a holiday. Come on Monday’.” Saturday was Independence day. When the family protested, staff at Chicalim gave Coelho two contact numbers and asked him to talk to the doctors in-charge of controlling the spread of swine flu.

“I called one of them, who advised me to immediately go to a private practitioner and start medication. He said that if the situation didn’t improve, then to come to the Chicalim Cottage hospital on Monday morning. I am shocked that Goa has not learnt from Maharshtra’s experience,” said Coelho. Health department officials have downplayed the incident and said that no swab samples are collected on Sunday.

17 August 2009,The Times of India, Goa edition

Sunday, August 16, 2009

Kayaking enthusiast drowns off Miramar

Kayaking enthusiast drowns off Miramar
TNN

PANAJI: A 32-year-old man died on Saturday when his regular kayaking foray into the sea off Miramar beach went wrong. He was not wearing a life jacket.

Panaji police said Nitin Nevrekar, owner of a car accessory shop at St Inez, went to Miramar beach with four friends and a young boy, the son of a friend, at 7am on Saturday. Two hours later he was declared brought dead at a private hospital in the city. His body was later shifted to the GMC.

Recounting what happened, the friends told police that Nevrekar who had rowed quite deep into the sea was tossed out of the kayak and was swept into the tide. Two friends who dived in to save him, managed to get him to shore after a struggle. When he didn’t respond to their first-aid attempts, they rushed him to a private hospital.

Claiming that Nevrekar refused to wear the life jacket they had carried along, the friends told the police, “He would never wear a life jacket. When we insisted that he wear it before going kayaking, he would tease us and say that while we might be scared, he isn’t.”

Commenting on the incident, businessman Annand Madgavkar, a member of the Miramar Baywatch Association, an NGO that puts up lifeguards on Miramar beach from 8am to 6pm, said, “There is no lifeguard from the tourism department on the beach and a kayak is not safe to be taken into the waves at Miramar in this weather.”

PSI Yogesh Pednekar is investigating the case.

16 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Rising food prices hit Goa Medical College patients

Rising food prices hit GMC patients
Preetu Nair, TNN

PANAJI: Rising food prices, coupled with the state’s seeming apathy, are taking a direct toll on the dietary intake of patients at the Goa Medical College and Hospital, Bambolim.

The state sanctions Rs 22 per patient per day—a sum, GMC officials say, is too meagre to supply patients with three big and two small nutritious meals. A proposal to up the amount to Rs 45 per patient per day has been pending with the government since the last three years, they add.

Health minister Vishwajit Rane told TOI he would take up the matter with the government, and added that the proposed amount is not enough either. “I have studied the issue, and with the present rise in food prices we need to increase the sanction from Rs 22 to Rs 75 to ensure that we provide nutritious food to patients.” He added that a new proposal would be made to the government soon.

Incidentally, in a recent move, the state upped the sanction to Rs 50 per patient per day for those institutes under the Directorate of Health Services. Confirming the move, director, Dr Rajnanda Desai, said, “We received a fresh order from the government about a week ago hiking the amount per patient per day to Rs 50.” The move is expected to benefit the in-patients at the two district hospitals and primary and community health centres.

Meanwhile, at GMC, the patients’ menu has undergone a drastic change over the last three years. While chicken, juice and fruits, except for banana, have been taken off the menu, the daily dose of fish-curry rice and a boiled egg have been allotted a thrice-weekly appearance. Bananas, point out doctors, are not advisable for diabetics. They add that till last year, such patients were given a sweet lime each. Hospital sources add that food quantity too has been reduced.

“We get rice from the civil supplies department. Everything else—milk, vegetables, eggs and fish—is purchased at market rates. Moreover, we feed about 1,000 plus in-patients everyday,” say hospital sources.

Pointing out that food is not simply a cost issue but also a “prevention-and-treatment matter”, GMC officials say, “On an average, a patient requires 2,000 Kcal and between 50 and 60 gram of protein everyday. With the present menu, though we meet the calorie requirement, we fall short on the protein content.”

Medical superintendent Dr Rajan Kunkolienkar says, “Patients have to be given a balanced diet. But with the present budget and with the increase in food prices, giving a balanced diet to the patient is difficult.”

16 August, 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Friday, August 14, 2009

Don't travel to flu-hit areas, says Goa govt advisory

Don't travel to flu-hit areas, says Goa govt advisory

People also asked to avoid Crowded places in First such advisory.

Panaji/ Margao: In an unprecendented move, the Goa government on Thursday issued an advisory to asking citizens " not to undertake non essential/ travel as far as possible to H1N1 affected states". The advisory released as an advertisement in newspapers , is signed by the director, directorate of health services, Rajnanda Desai.

Speaking to TOI Desai said, " We have also advised people to avoid crowded places." She said tht due to the weekend holidays for Independence day and Ganesh Chaturthi , a number of tourists would be entering the state and flocking Ganesh Mandals, which the directorate was advising against.

"Mandals may get crowded and it would be difficult to curb the spread of the virus," said Desai.

The only state so far to ask it citizens not to travel to flu-hit areas has been Tamil Nadu, when a minister recently asked people not to travel to Maharashtra , leading to a controversy with the Maharashtra health minister questioning the one state's advisory against another and saying that if at all such a directive is needed to be issued, it should have come from the Centre. The Tamil Nadu minister later went on the defensive and claimed that all he said was that people should be careful while travelling in those areas.

Meanwhile, panic is leading to long ques at Chicalim Cottage hospital with 50-60 turning up for tests daily. This has forced the government to post two rapid response teams, comprising an epidemologist and microbiologist each, at the hospital. "People are scared. Many who do not have swine flu symptoms get upset when we do not collect their swab samples. Others get irritated but we counsel them and they understand," said health officials.

14 August, 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Acquitals, inquest dams cop

Acquitals, inquest dams cop

Preetu Nair, TNN

PANAJI: Police delay in registering cases, discrepancy in witness statements and hurt certificates, investigating officer's failure in visiting
the crime scene, stereo type recording of statements, panchnamas drawn at police station due to which panchas are unable to stand the test of cross examination, are prime reasons for majority of cases ending in acquittal in the courts.

Amidst allegations of a poor conviction rate, senior police officials after going through cases and interacting with public prosecutors and the director of prosecution arrived at some of the major reasons for acquittals in cases. They found that it is not just stock panchas and witnesses turning hostile, that are responsible for the cases falling in the court. The reasons were discussed at a workshop for police sub-inspectors of North Goa on Saturday.

Explaining the reasons for acquittals, especially in hurt cases, SP (traffic) Arvind Gawas said, "Delay in registering of FIR or medical examination of victim, discrepancy in hurt certificate, failure to get the accused medically examined and ascertaining the blood group of both victim and accused, failure to record statement of witnesses mentioned in complaint and delay in recovery of assault weapon and failure to ensure that it is sealed are some of the reasons for acquittals in hurt cases."

He said that few common errors such as failure to mention the kind of light used if the panchnama was drawn at night, failure to record the photographer's statement and attach photo negatives and converting a non cognizable case to a first information report without the court's permission leads to acquittal in court.

Further, SP (coastal security) O R Kudtarkar said that contradiction in the deposition of the witnesses and recording the witnesses' statement in a stereo type manner, besides failure to draw panchnama with due care are reasons for acquittal.

"If the investigating officer suspects that the witness may turn hostile, then he should ensure that the witnesses' statement is recorded u/s 164 (5) CrPC by a special magistrate. Also in a large number of cases, panch witnesses are not taken to the spot and the panchanama is actually prepared at the police station (by calling some stock panch witnesses) and as soon as circumstantial evidence is collected it has to be immediately deposited in the malkhana. But the same is invariably not done," added SP Kudtarkar.
The purpose of the workshop was to help newly recruited PSIs to understand the reasons for acquittals and ensure that they provide a consistent police response. SP (north) Bosco George said, "During my visits to police stations and on interacting with the new PSIs and going through their investigation and case papers, it was felt that they needed to be brushed up on the latest amendments and trained in proper documentation."

In the just concluded assembly session, the police had faced flak for a poor conviction rate. In 2005, out of the 2,119 cases registered under the Indian Penal Code, 1,316 cases were solved while 350 cases ended in acquittals or a discharge of the accused by the court.

It was a similar story in the following years, when in 2006, out of the 2,204 cases, 1,355 cases were detected while 247 saw acquittals or discharge of the accused. In 2007, of 2,479 cases, 1,616 cases were solved, while 137 cases were discharged by the court. In 2008 out of the 2,742 cases, 1,803 cases were solved and 33 cases ended in acquittals. Also in matka cases, two accused were convicted.

14 August, 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Wednesday, August 12, 2009

Human Swine Influenza: a pandemic threat

Human Swine Influenza: a pandemic threat
CD Alert, Monthly Newsletter of National Institute of Communicable Diseases,
Directorate General of Health Services, Government of India
March- April 2009 Vol.12 : No.8

Special Issue: Human Swine Influenza: a pandemic threat


INTRODUCTION
Influenza (Flu) pandemics are caused by new influenza viruses that have recently adapted to humans and resemble major natural disasters both in terms of recurrence and magnitude. The influenza virus, known to be circulating as a pathogen in the human population since at least the 16th century is notable for its unique
ability to cause recurrent epidemics and global pandemics. Genetic re-assortments in the influenza virus cause fast and unpredictable antigenic changes in important immune targets leading to recurrent epidemics of febrile respiratory disease every 1 to 3 years, consistently necessitated the development of new vaccines. Each century has seen some pandemics rapidly progressing to all parts of the world due to emergence of a novel virus to which the overall population holds no immunity.

SWINE FLU IN PIGS
Swine Influenza (swine flu) is a respiratory disease of pigs caused by type A influenza virus that regularly causes outbreaks of influenza in pigs. Swine flu viruses cause high levels of illness and low death rates in pigs. Swine influenza viruses usually circulate among swine throughout the year, but most outbreaks occur during the late fall and winter months similar to outbreaks in humans. The
classical swine flu virus (an influenza type A H1N1 virus) was first isolated from a pig in 1930. H3N2 influenza viruses began circulating among pigs from 1998. The H3N2
viruses initially were introduced into the pig population from humans. Like all influenza viruses, swine flu viruses change constantly. Pigs can be infected by
avian influenza, human influenza viruses as well as swine influenza viruses and hence the pigs are known to be a mixing vessel. When influenza viruses from different species infect pigs, the viruses can re-assort (i.e. swap genes)
and new viruses , a mix of swine, human and/or avian influenza viruses - can emerge leading to development of new novel strain for which human beings do not have no immunity. There are four main influenza type A virus subtypes that have been isolated in pigs: H1N1, H1N2, H3N1 and H3N2. However, most of the recently
isolated influenza viruses from pigs have been H1N1 viruses.Swine flu virus spreads mostly through close contact among pigs and possibly from contaminated objects moving between infected and uninfected pigs. Symptoms of swine flu in
pigs can include sudden onset of fever, depression, coughing (barking), discharge
from the nose or eyes, sneezing, breathing difficulties, eye redness or inflammation, and going off feed.

SWINE FLU IN HUMANS

Swine flu viruses do not normally infect humans. However, sporadic human infections with swine flu have occurred. Most commonly, these cases occur in persons having direct exposure to pigs. In addition, there have been sporadic cases of
one person spreading swine flu to others. Occasional human swine influenza virus
infection occurs every one to two years in the U.S., but from December 2005 through February 2009, 12 cases of human infection with swine influenza have been reported.

SWINE FLU OUTBREAK
Recently, human cases of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection have been recently
reported in several countries. This is a novel influenza A virus that has not been identified in people before, and human-to-human transmission of the virus appears to be ongoing and thus represents a real pandemic threat. WHO has upgraded the phasing of pandemic influenza from Phase -3 to Phase - 5

A virus which infects humans, swine, birds, poultry and horses and other animals, but
wild birds are the natural hosts for these viruses. Influenza type A viruses are divided into subtypes and named on the basis of two proteins on the surface of the virus: hemagglutinin (HA) and neuraminidase (NA. There are 16 known HA
subtypes and 9 known NA subtypes. Many different combinations of HA and NA proteins are possible. . For example, an “H1N1” virus has an HA 1 protein and an NA 1 protein Only some influenza A subtypes (i.e., H1N1, H1N2, and H3N2) are currently in general circulation among people. Other subtypes are found most commonly in other
animal species.

Current Situation: The current situation regarding the outbreak of swine influenza
A(H1N1) is evolving rapidly. As on 29 April 2009, nine countries have officially reported 148 confirmed cases of swine influenza A/H1N1 infection. Of these, United States has reported 91 laboratory confirmed human cases, including one death. Mexico has reported 26 confirmed human cases including seven deaths.

The following countries have reported laboratory confirmed cases with no deaths -
Austria (1), Canada (13), Germany (3), Israel (2), New Zealand (3), Spain (4) and the United Kingdom (5). All these cases have history of travel to Mexico.
Unlike the experience in Mexico, the United States is currently reporting infection by the identical virus strain or less severe clinical spectrum of disease. Mexican health officials have reported several hundred suspect cases, including several deaths associated with swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection. In Mexico,
many patients have experienced rapidly progressive pneumonia, respiratory failure and
acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) requiring mechanical ventilation.

INFLUENZA SURVEILLANCE
Surveillance is the foundation of all efforts to understand and control influenza. The monitoring of influenza disease patterns is essential for identification of high risk groups, planning of prevention and response activities for complications
and for estimating the burden of disease in terms of health and economic impact.
It is important to use standardized case definitions that enable comparisons between different areas within a country and also between countries. There are two case definitions used by the influenza surveillance system:

1. Influenza-like illness (ILI) is defined (according to WHO criteria) as:

• Sudden onset of a fever over 38°C, AND
• Cough or sore throat, AND
• An absence of other diagnoses.

2. Severe Acute Respiratory Infections (SARI):. For persons ≥ 5 years the definition for SARI is adapted from the WHO protocol on rapid response:

• Sudden onset of fever over 38°C, AND
• Cough or sore throat, AND
• Shortness of breath or difficulty in breathing, AND
• Requiring hospital admission

For children <5 years old: definition is adapted from the program for Integrated Management of Childhood Illness (IMCI):
Any child <5 years old clinically suspected of having Pneumonia or Severe/very Severe
Pneumonia and requiring hospital admission.

3. Confirmed case of influenza is defined as any
case with laboratory test results positive for influenza virus.
influenza virus.

CASE DEFINITION OF SWINE FLU IN HUMANS

A suspected case of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection is defined as a person with acute febrile respiratory illness (fever ≥ 380 C) with onset.

*within 7 days of close contact with a person who is a confirmed case of swine influenza A (H1N1 virus infection, or

* within 7 days of travel to areas where there are one or more confirmed swine influenza A(H1N1) cases, or

* resides in a community where there are one or more confirmed swine influenza cases.

A probable case of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection is defined as a person with an acute febrile respiratory illness who:
* is positive for influenza A, but unsubtypable for H1 and H3 by influenza RT-PCR or reagents used to detect seasonal influenza virus infection,
or

* is positive for influenza A by an influenza rapid test or an influenza immunofluorescence assay (IFA) plus meets criteria for a suspected case, or

*individual with a clinically compatible illness who died of an unexplained acute respiratory illness who is considered to be epidemiologically linked
to a probable or confirmed case.

A confirmed case of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection is defined as a person with an acute febrile respiratory illness with laboratory confirmed swine
influenza A (H1N1) virus infection at WHO approved laboratories by one or more of the following tests:

 Real Time PCR
 Viral culture
 Four-fold rise in swine influenza A (H1N1) virus specific neutralizing antibodies.


OTHER DEFINITIONS
Close contact is defined within 6 feet of an ill person who is a confirmed, probable or suspected case of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection during the infectious period. Acute respiratory illness is defined as illness of recent onset with least two of the following: rhinorrhea or nasal congestion, sore throat, cough (with or without fever).

High-risk group for complications of influenza is defined as a person such as:

 resident of institutions for elderly people and the disabled;
 people with certain chronic health conditions (chronic heart or lung disease, metabolic or renal disease or immunodeficiencies);
 elderly people and very young children. Infectious period: The infectious period for a confirmed case of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection is defined as 1 day prior to the onset of illness to 7 days after onset.

TRANSMISSION
 Influenza viruses can be directly transmitted from pigs to people and from people to pigs.

 Human infection with flu viruses from pigs are most likely to occur when people are in close proximity to infected pigs, such as in pig barns
and livestock exhibits housing pigs at fairs.
 Human-to-human transmission of swine flu can
also occur. This is thought to occur in the same
way as seasonal flu which is mainly person-toperson
transmission through coughing or
sneezing by people infected with the influenza
virus.
 Disease spreads very quickly among the population especially in crowded places.
 Cold and dry weather enables the virus to survive longer outside the body than in other conditions and, as a consequence, seasonal epidemics in temperate areas appear in winter.
 People may become infected by touching/handling something contaminated with
flu viruses on it and then touching their mouth or nose.
 Swine influenza viruses are not transmitted by food.
 Eating properly handled and cooked pork (at an internal temperature of ≥160°F) and pork products is safe.

SYMPTOMS
The symptoms of swine flu in people are expected to be similar to the symptoms of
regular human seasonal influenza like fever, lethargy, lack of appetite and cough. Some people have also reported runny nose, sore throat, nausea, vomiting and diarrhoea.

DIAGNOSIS OF SWINE FLU
For diagnosis of swine influenza A infection, respiratory specimen would generally need to be collected within the first 4 to 5 days of illness (when an infected person is most likely to be shedding virus). However, some persons, especially children, may shed virus for 10 days or longer.

Sample Collection & Laboratory Diagnosis

 Sample Collection and handling is same as for human avian flu or seasonal
influenza like illness (Refer CD Alert on AI).
 Sample Collection: should be done by the treating doctor who is managing the case.
 Preferred respiratory samples : nasopharyngeal swab and throat swab
 Storage of Samples: all samples should be kept at 2-80C until they can be placed at -700C.
 Transportation of Samples: Clinical samples should be transported on dry ice
in triple packaging. All samples should be labeled clearly and include patient’s
complete information and should be sent to NIV, Pune or NICD, Delhi within 24 hours
for further investigations.

 Laboratory biosafety measures should be followed for collection, storage,
packaging and shipping of influenza samples.
 Available Laboratory tests:
 Rapid Antigen Tests: not as sensitive as other available tests.
 RT-PCR
 Virus isolation
 Virus Genome Sequencing
 Four-fold rise in swine influenza A (H1N1) virus specific neutralizing
antibodies. It is important to note that samples from all cases, once the Pandemic starts, are not required to be tested.

Important Contact Numbers:
Outbreak Monitoring Cell (Control Room,
NICD): 011-23921401 EMR Control room (Ministry of Health and
family Welfare: 011- 23061469
Important Websites:
www.mohfw.nic.in; www.nicd.nic.in

PREVENTIVE MEASURES
There is currently no vaccine available against human swine influenza. One has
to follow proper hand hygiene and respiratory etiquettes.

Do’s and Don’ts:
 Avoid close contact with people who are having respiratory illness.
 Sick persons should keep distance from others.
 If possible, stay at home, away from work,school, and public places when you are
sick.
 Cover your mouth and nose with a tissue or handkerchief when coughing or sneezing.
 If you have no tissue or handkerchief you should not clean the nose with the hands
but with the cuff of your shirt or clothes.
 Washing your hands often with soap or alcohol based hand wash will help protect
from germs.
 Get plenty of sleep, be physically active, manage your stress, drink plenty of fluids, and eat nutritious food.

Persons who develop influenza-like-illness (ILI) (fever with either cough or sore throat) should be strongly encouraged to selfisolate in their home for 7 days after the onset of illness or at least 24 hours after symptoms have resolved, whichever is
longer.
 Persons who experience ILI and wish to seek medical care should contact their
health care providers to report illness (by telephone or other remote means) before
seeking care at a clinic, physician’s office, or hospital.
 Persons who have difficulty breathing or shortness of breath should seek immediate
medical attention and report to the nearby hospital.
 If ill persons must go into the community (e.g., to seek medical care) they should
wear a face mask to reduce the risk of spreading the virus in the community.
 If a face mask is unavailable, ill persons needing to go into the community should
use a handkerchief or tissues to cover any coughing and sneezing.
 Persons in home isolation and their household members should be given infection control instructions like frequent hand washing with soap and water; use of
alcohol-based hand gels (containing at least 60%alcohol).
 When the ill person is within 6 feet of others at home, the ill person should wear a face mask, if available or handkerchief or tissues.

 Household contacts who are well should:
o remain home at the earliest sign of illness;
o minimize contact in the community to the
extent possible;
o designate a single household family
member as the ill person’s caregiver to
minimize interactions with asymptomatic
persons.

 Precautions for School children:
o Schools with a confirmed or a suspected case should be considered for closure.
o All school or childcare related gatherings should be cancelled and encourage
parents and students to avoid congregating outside of the school.
o Schools and childcare facilities should bar students for a time period to be evaluated on an ongoing basis depending upon epidemiological findings.
o Schools and childcare facilities should consult with their local or state health
departments for guidance on reopening. If no additional confirmed or suspected
cases are identified among students (or school-based personnel) for a period of 7
days, schools may consider reopening.
o Schools and childcare facilities in unaffected areas should begin to prepare
for the possibility of school or childcare facility closure.

 Social Distancing Interventions:
o Large gatherings linked to settings or institutions with laboratory-confirmed
cases should be cancelled, for example a school event linked to a school with cases;
other large gatherings in the community may not need to be cancelled at this time.
o Additional social distancing measures are currently not recommended.
o Persons with underlying medical conditions who are at high risk for complications of influenza may wish to consider avoiding large gatherings.

SWINE INFLUENZA A (H1N1) VIRUS: BIOSAFETY GUIDELINES FOR LABORATORY WORKERS
Laboratory workers who may be processing or performing diagnostic testing on clinical specimens from patients with suspected swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection, or performing viral isolation. Diagnostic laboratory work on clinical samples from patients who are suspected cases of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection should be conducted in a BSL2 laboratory. All sample manipulations should be done inside a biosafety cabinet.

Viral isolation on clinical specimens from patients who are suspected cases of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus infection should be performed in a BSL2 laboratory with BSL3 practices (enhanced BSL2 conditions).

Additional precautions include:

 Recommended Personal Protective Equipment
(based on site specific risk assessment )
 Respiratory protection – fit-tested N95
respirator or higher level of protection.
 Shoe covers
 Closed-front gown
 Double gloves
 Eye protection (goggles or face shields)
 Appropriate disinfectants

o 70% Ethanol
o 5% Lysol
o 10% Bleach
All personnel should self monitor for fever and other symptoms of Swine influenza. Any illness should be reported to the supervisor immediately.

For personnel who had unprotected exposure or a known breach in personal protective equipment to clinical material or live virus from a confirmed case of swine influenza A (H1N1), antiviral chemoprophylaxis with oseltamivir for 7 days after
exposure can be considered.

Waste disposal

All waste disposal procedures should be followed as outlined in the respective facility standard laboratory operating procedures.

ANTIVIRAL TREATMENT

Oseltamivir is the recommended drug both for prophylaxis and treatment.

Supportive therapy includes:

- IV Fluids.
- Parentral nutrition.
- Oxygen therapy/ ventilatory support.
- Antibiotics for secondary infection.
- Vasopressors for shock.
- Paracetamol or ibuprofen is prescribed for fever, myalgia and headache. Patient is advised to drink plenty of fluids. Smokers should avoid smoking. For sore throat, short course of topical decongestants, saline nasal drops, throat lozenges and steam inhalation may be beneficial.

- Salicylate / aspirin is strictly contra-indicated in any influenza patient due to its potential to cause Reye’s syndrome.

The suspected cases would be constantly monitored for clinical / radiological evidence of lower respiratory tract infection and for hypoxia (respiratory rate, oxygen saturation, level of consciousness).

Adult patients should be discharged 7 days after symptoms have subsided.

Children should be discharged 14 days after symptoms have subsided. The family of patients discharged earlier should be educated on personal hygiene and infection control measures at home; children should not attend school during this period.

ANTIVIRAL CHEMOPROPHYLAXIS
Prophylaxis is given to:

 All close contacts of suspected, probable and confirmed cases. Close contacts include household /social contacts, workplace or school contacts, fellow travelers etc.
 All health care personnel coming in contact with suspected, probable or confirmed cases

 Oseltamivir is the drug of choice.
 Prophylaxis should be provided till 10 days after last exposure (maximum period of 6 weeks)
 By Weight:
For weight <15kg: 30 mg OD
15-23kg: 45 mg OD
24-<40kg: 60 mg OD
≥40kg: 75 mg OD
 For infants:
 < 3 months: not recommended unless situation judged critical due to limited data
on use in this age group
 3-5 months: 20 mg OD
 6-11 months: 25 mg OD
 Close Contacts of suspected, probable and confirmed cases should be advised to remain at home (voluntary home quarantine) for at least 7 days after the last contact with the case. Monitoring of fever should be done for at least 7 days. Prompt testing and hospitalization must be done when symptoms are reported.
All suspected cases, clusters of ILI/SARI cases need to be notified to the State Health Authorities and the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, Govt. of India (Director, EMR and Director, NICD)

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
What is swine flu?
Swine Influenza (swine flu) is a respiratory disease of pigs caused by type A influenza viruses that causes regular outbreaks in pigs. People do not normally get swine flu, but human infections can and do happen. Swine flu viruses have been reported to spread from person-to-person, but in the past, this transmission was limited and not sustained beyond three people.

Are there human infections with swine flu in India.?

In late March and early April 2009, cases of human infection with swine influenza A (H1N1) viruses were first reported in Southern California and near San Antonio, Texas. Other U.S. states have reported cases of swine flu infection in humans and cases have been reported internationally as well. Central & State Health Authorities are monitoring the situation

Is this swine flu virus contagious?
CDC has determined that this swine influenza A (H1N1) virus is contagious and is spreading from human to human. However, at this time, it is not known how easily the virus spreads between people and between countries.

What are the signs and symptoms of swine flu in people?
The symptoms of swine flu in people are similar to the symptoms of regular human flu and include fever, cough, sore throat, body aches, headache, chills and fatigue. Some people have reported diarrhea and vomiting associated with swine flu. In
the past, severe illness (pneumonia and respiratory failure) and deaths have been reported with swine flu infection in people. Like seasonal flu, swine flu may
cause a worsening of underlying chronic medical conditions.

How does swine flu spread?

Spread of swine influenza A (H1N1) virus is thought to be happening in the same way as that of seasonal flu. Flu viruses are spread mainly from person to person through coughing or sneezing of people with influenza. Sometimes people may become infected
by touching something with flu viruses on it and then touching their mouth or nose.

How can someone with the flu infect someone else?
Infected people may be able to infect others beginning 1 day before symptoms develop and up to 7 or more days after becoming sick.

What should I do to keep from getting the flu?

First and most important: wash your hands frequently. Try to stay in good general health. Get plenty of sleep, be physically active, manage your stress, drink plenty of fluids, and eat nutritious food. Avoid touching surfaces that may be contaminated
with the flu virus. Avoid close contact with people having respiratory illness.

Are there medicines to treat swine flu?
Yes. The use of oseltamivir for the treatment and/or prevention of infection with these swine influenza viruses is recommended. Antiviral drugs fight against
the flu by keeping flu viruses from reproducing in your body. If you get sick, antiviral drugs can make your illness milder and make you feel better faster.
They may also prevent serious flu complications. For treatment, antiviral drugs work best if started soon after getting sick (within 2 days of symptoms). They
are currently available with hospitals and are to be administered under supervision of clinicians.

How long can an infected person spread swine flu to others?
People with swine influenza virus infection should be considered potentially contagious as long as they are symptomatic and possibly for up to 7 days following
onset of illness. Children, especially younger children, might potentially be contagious for longer periods.

What surfaces are most likely to be sources of contamination?

Germs can be spread when a person touches something that is contaminated with germs and then touches his or her eyes, nose, or mouth.Droplets from a cough or sneeze of an infected person move through the air.

How long can viruses live outside the body?
We know that some viruses and bacteria can live 2 hours or longer on surfaces like cafeteria tables, doorknobs, and desks. Frequent hand washing will help you reduce the chance of getting contamination from these common surfaces

What can I do to protect myself from getting sick?
Currently available seasonal influenza vaccine does not protect against swine flu. There are everyday actions that can help prevent the spread of germs that cause respiratory illnesses like influenza. Take these everyday steps to protect your health:
 Cover your nose and mouth with a tissue when you cough or sneeze. Throw the tissue in the trash after you use it.
 Wash your hands often with soap and water, especially after you cough or sneeze. Alcoholbased hand cleaners are also effective.
 Avoid touching your eyes, nose or mouth. Germs spread this way.
 Try to avoid close contact with people having respiratory illness.
 If one gets sick with influenza, one must stay at home, away from work or school and limit contact with others to keep from infecting them. However, if one is having any respiratory distress, one should report to a nearby hospital.

What should I do if I get sick?
If you live in areas where swine influenza cases have been identified and become ill with influenzalike symptoms e.g. fever, body aches, runny nose, sore throat, nausea, or vomiting or diarrhea, you may contact their health care provider, particularly if
you are worried about your symptoms. Your health care provider will determine whether influenza testing or treatment is needed. If you are sick, you should stay home and avoid contact with other people as much as possible to keep from spreading your illness to others. If you become ill and experience any of the following
warning signs, seek emergency medical care.

In children emergency warning signs that need urgent medical attention include:
 Fast breathing or trouble breathing
 Bluish skin color
 Not drinking enough fluids/eating food
 Not waking up or not interacting
 Being so irritable that the child does not want to be held
 Flu-like symptoms improve but then return with fever and worse cough
 Fever with a rash In adults, emergency warning signs that need urgent medical attention include:
 Difficulty breathing or shortness of breath
 Pain or pressure in the chest or abdomen
 Sudden dizziness
 Confusion
 Severe or persistent vomiting

Can I get swine influenza from eating or preparing pork?

No. swine influenza viruses are not spread by food. Eating properly handled and cooked pork products is safe.

...about CD Alert
CDAlert is a monthly newsletter of the National Institute of Communicable Diseases (NICD) , Directorate General of Health Services, to disseminate information on various aspects of communicable diseases to medical fraternity and health
administrators. The newsletter may be reproduced, in part or whole, for educational purposes.
Chief Editor: Dr. R. K. Srivastava
Editorial Board: Dr. Shiv Lal, Dr. R. L. Ichhpujani, Dr. Shashi Khare, Dr. A. K. Harit
Guest Editor (Authors): Dr Archana Aravindan, Dr. Avdhesh Kumar, Dr Arti Bahl, Dr Shashi Khare
Publisher: Director, National Institute of Communicable Diseases, 22 Shamnath Marg, Delhi 110 054 Tel: 011-23971272, 23971060 Fax : 011-23922677
E-mail: dirnicd@bol.net.in and dirnicd@gmail.com Website: www.nicd.nic.in
Acknowledgement: Financial assistance by WHO/USAID is duly acknowledged.

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

Goa Cops being transferred at behest of policitians

Cops being transferred at behest of policitians

Preetu Nair, TNN

PANAJI: Between July 2 and July 10, the police department received four requests from PIs seeking transfers citing personal reasons. That is not
surprising, but what has raised eyebrows is the fact that all the applicants apparently went out of their way to clearly mention that there is no "compulsion" or "pressure" from anyone to seek transfer.

Details acquired under the RTI Act show that none of them had completed the minimum tenure of two years prescribed by the Supreme Court for police station in-charge. IGP KD Singh called the officers to the "orderly room" to discuss their applications on July 15 and the Police Establishment Board approved the transfers the following day. All the officers got the postings of their choice.

PI Tushar Vernekar, who had taken charge of Calangute police station as officer in charge on November 2007, asked to be relieved on July 10. The IGP said in his file noting that that Vernekar was a resident of Verem, Bardez, that he was the only son of the family. "His mother is 65 years old..." and he is not being able to take proper care of her since "most of the time he is busy at police station". Vernekar would prefer to work at airport immigration or anywhere in the Panaji area, the IGP's noting said. Vernekar got the posting of his choice.

PI Rajan Prabhudessai, who took over as in-charge of the Margao police station on May 19, 2008, filed his transfer application on July 8, 2009. The IGP noted his reason for seeking transfer: "It is a busy police station and he is not able to look after his wife and only child, therefore he wants to work at (a) less burdened police station. He has not been compelled by anyone for asking his transfer from Margao PS. He requested for transfer at Verna PS or Konkan railway PS." PI Rajan was later posted as PI Verna.

PI Santosh Dessai, who had completed just 15 months at Quepem police station, justified his transfer saying he has to bring his mother frequently for treatment to Margao and that due to the long distance it was difficult for him to look after her treatment. Quepem PS being close to his villageCuncolimit is difficult for him to function at the police station and requested for a posting anywhere in Margao sub-division. He was posted as Margao PS in-charge.

Similarly, PI D G Angle said his parents, who stay in Vasco, had health problems due to old age and asked for a transfer to the Vasco traffic cell. In his letter, the officer, who had been in charge of Maina Curtorim PS for last eight months, further wrote, "Moreover, being a local in Margao area also causes a lot of problem of working in the area where people are known to you. I have served last eight years in Margao division and due to the circumstances mentioned above prefer to be transferred and posted at Vasco traffic which at present is vacant". His wish too was granted.

Senior police officers claim that these letters were written at the behest of political leaders in an effort to override the requirements for transfer of officers in charge of police stations as laid down by the Supreme Court.

"Police officers who are not in the good books of politicians are often pressurised to seek transfer in this manner," said a senior police officer.

9 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Saturday, August 08, 2009

Major credit card racket busted, 6 held

Major credit card racket busted, 6 held
Preetu Nair ,TNN

PANAJI: Panaji police busted an international credit card fraud involving cloning of cards and using them to gamble in offshore casinos in Goa on
Friday.

Police say they cracked the racket after arresting six persons from Mumbai and suspect that those arrested may allegedly be part of a group which either collected or hacked legitimate credit cards from Europeans and encoded them on fake credit cards created in India.

“We have arrested six persons in a credit card scam and we suspect it to be an international racket involving several persons. We have got 14 days police custody of the accused and further investigations are on,” Panaji police station in-charge (I) PI Sandesh Chodankar said.

Police suspect this to be just the tip of the iceberg and hundreds of credit and debit cards owners, especially from Europe, could be affected.

“The first four digits of a card indicate the card’s originating country. A majority of them are from European countries, especially Germany and England,” said police sources.

A team led by Panaji police station in-charge (II) PI Francisco Corte arrested five persons on Thursday afternoon for suspicious behaviour. The sixth person Bhupendra Shukla, staying in another city hotel
, was arrested when he approached the Panaji police station on Thursday itself and attempted to furnish a character certificate in support of his five friends.

Police said the six persons had earlier visited Goa in July. Five of them arrived by air on Wednesday from Mumbai and booked into a hotel at Miramar and visited an offshore casino the same day, where they allegedly used the fake credit cards to earn “white money”.

8 August 2009,The Times of India, Goa edition

Thursday, August 06, 2009

Goa may invoke Epidemic Act if flu doesn’t abate globally by Oct: Rane

Goa may invoke Epidemic Act if flu doesn’t abate globally by Oct: Rane

TNN
PANAJI: Goa will invoke the Epidemic Control Act, 1897 if the swine flu pandemic doesn’t abate by September-end, health minister Vishwajit Rane
said on Wednesday. “Before the tourism season starts, we will review the worldwide situation and if it doesn’t improve, we will invoke ECA,” said Rane.

Rane’s announcement comes a day after the Maharashtra government invoked the act in Pune and Satara districts. “Maharashtra invoked it because there are thousands of international guests arriving at its (Mumbai) airport. We don’t feel it is required in Goa at the moment, but once the tourist season starts we will receive many international tourists,” said Rane.

August 6, 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Paramedics to boost state's health set-up

Paramedics to boost state's health set-up
TNN

PANAJI: Goa will be the first state in the country to have paramedics posted in ambulances and emergency rooms in rural dispensaries. They will
also help casualty doctors at the two district hospitals and at the Goa Medical College and Hospital, Bambolim.

Announcing this at the launch of paramedical services in the state on Wednesday, health minister Vishwajit Rane said, "We are the first state in the country to have paramedical staff in ambulances and emergency rooms. The concept of emergency rooms where patients will be stabilized and then taken for further treatment, is also a new one in India and will prove to be really beneficial for cardiac emergency patients." He added that emergency rooms will be set up and the casualty wards in the two district hospitals and GMC will be strengthened with the help of paramedics.

The Goa government has tied up with the Emergency Management and Research Institute (EMRI) that presently runs the 108 emergency service in the state, for the paramedic service. Thirty paramedics will start work in the next week at five emergency rooms in the state, ambulances, district hospitals and the GMC casualty ward.

In the first phase, five emergency rooms will be set up at Canacona, Curchorem, Chicalim, Sanquelim and Candolim. In the second phase, emergency rooms will be set up in the urban centres at Panaji and Siolim.

Chief minister Digambar Kamat said, "If the patient is given treatment on time then 50% of grievances against the health services will be solved. With paramedical staff, people will once again be reassured that the state is concerned about people's health."

Incidentally, it has been time and again alleged that Goa lacks basic facilities in government hospitals, especially in rural areas. Accepting the problem, Rane said, "We are trying to address each and every issue and we are trying to improve the situation in rural areas. We are putting up state of the art infrastructure."

The paramedics have done a two-year course with EMRI and have had six months of internship at hospital and ambulance services across the country, Rajesh Waghmare, EMRI in-charge in Goa said. "With paramedical staff being deployed in emergency rooms and ambulances we will be able to save patients within the golden hour. At present we save 250 lives per month and now with these facilities in place, we expect to save a minimum of 500 lives in a month." Goa also plans to set-up a training centre for paramedics in the state with EMRI's help.

To a question on whether the paramedics are from Goa and whether they are well versed in the local language, Rane said they would be given a month and a half's training in communication to enable them to communicate in the local language. But I must admit that I don't like being asked whether the paramedical staff are Goans or non-Goans. They are all Indians and their job is to save lives and when you are saving life, communication is not an issue," he said.

Rane refused to divulge the exact amount being spent by the government to set up emergency rooms and appoint paramedical staff. "Where people's lives are concerned, we shouldn't count the amount," he said.

6 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Wednesday, August 05, 2009

Dr Jose D'Sa is new nodal officer for swine flu
TNN
PANAJI: The government on Tuesday replaced Dr Rajendra Tamba as its nodal officer for swine flu following his comments on the lack of funds for
the project. He has been transferred to the rural medical dispensary at Chorao.

Dr Jose D'Sa, health officer with the National Vector Borne Disease Control Programme, has been appointed in his place. D'Sa took over the additional charge on Tuesday.

Tamba, who has also been stripped of the post of state epidermologist, earned the state government's ire after he released a media statement claiming that the state's swine flu monitoring programme was facing a financial crunch.

"The expenses so far were made from funds under the Integrated Disease Surveillance Project (IDSP) received from the government of India, which are now exhausted," Tamba had said.

Maintaining that there was no dearth of funds for the programme, health minister Vishwajit Rane said on Monday that such statements by the nodal officer could portray a wrong image of the state across the country. "It was not right to make such a statement. It was against the interest of the state," Rane said.

TOI had reported over a fortnight ago that Tamba had written to chief minister Digambar Kamat asking to be relieved from the post. He had reportedly alleged in the letter that the state health authorities were not cooperating with him and not doing enough for the quarantined patients.

Goa has so far recorded six confirmed cases of swine flu and has set up two facilities to isolate the suspected and confirmed patients.

August 05,2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Monday, August 03, 2009

Fiona give police the slip as she feared arrest by Goa Police

Fiona give police the slip
Preetu Nair , TNN


Panaji: Anjuna police looking out for Fiona MacKeown, mother of murdered British teenager Scarlett Keeling , were caught napping, as Fiona entered the country a fortnight ago, recorded her statement, with the CBI in Mumbai and left. Fiona told TOI from her home in Devon, UK, " “I came to Mumbai to talk to the CBI as they were refused permission by the High Court in Goa to come to the UK to speak to me”.

The CBI was entrusted with the task of probing the rape and murder of 15-year-old Scarlett at Anjuna beach in February 2008, after investigations by the Goa police came under a cloud. Last month, the High court of Bombay at Goa dismissed CBI’s plea to give letter Rogatory to interrogate Fiona and another witness, Briton. The court, however, gave CBI three months extension to investigate the case.

Fiona feared arrest by Goa Police
Preetu Nair, TNN

Panaji:Fiona Mackeown mother of British teenager Scarlett Keeing who was murdered in Anjuna in 2008, came to Mumbai on July 18 from Britain and returned on July 21, after recording her statement with the CBI

“I was worried that the Goa police may try to arrest me or cause me other problems like stopping me from leaving which was why no one was informed about the trip”, she told TOI from her home in Devon, UK.

Fiona , who has accused the Goa police of a cover up last year, faces charges of negligence of her minor daughter under the Goa Children's Act 2003. Anjuna police that is investigating the case has sought permission from the government to go to UK to question Fiona.

Though Fiona wanted to visit Goa, fears that the local police may arrest her kept her away . “I would have loved to come to Goa. I still love Goa and think very warmly of the wonderful people I met there but there is a very dark element to Goa and this alone would have left me feeling very unsafe there”, she said

Fiona said that it is not just the police that she is worried about, but also those involved in Scarlett's murder. "My daughter’s murderers are powerful men, who have stated publicly that I have been harassing them and that their business has been affected by all of this. They definitely had a vested interest in me not speaking to the CBI. After all, they were powerful enough to instigate the cover up”, she alleged.

Happy with the progress of the CBI investigations, Fiona said, “They answered all of my questions and I left feeling very positive about the investigation and about the Indian judicial system”.

She. however, refused to divulge details about her meeting with the CBI stating that the CBI has not yet finished the investigations. “I was asked not to talk about the details of our meeting so as not to jeopardize the case. But I can tell you that I was able to provide them with information that they did not have”, said Fiona, adding “At the moment I am beginning to see a light at the end of a very long tunnel and just look forward to the investigation being over so that I can finally bring Scarlett home and burying her.”

August 3, The Times of India, Goa edition

Child maid's mother too received money

Child maid's mother too received money
PANAJI: The mother of the 10-year-old girl, recovering at Goa medical college and hospital from torture wounds allegedly inflicted her employers,has admitted to the police that she accepted money from the accused to send her minor child to work as a domestic maid at their home.

Police sources revealed that in her statement, the mother said she had taken Rs 1,500 from Porvorim based civil engineer Audumber (Shubham) Pednekar to allow her daughter to work in his house. However, the minor in her statement to the police had revealed that while her mother was paid Rs 2,000, her grandmother received Rs 800 and another person from Panaji, where she worked for few days, was the recipient of Rs 4,000 all paid by Shubham.

Though police made efforts to interrogate the mother again, they say they found her in an inebriated state most times. "We will thoroughly interrogate the mother again," said police sources.

In her statement, the mother told the police that she lived in Gadak, Karnataka and had on one occasion interacted with her daughter in the Pednekar household during the course of her daughter's employment.

Speaking to people she has befriended in the hospital the girl alleged that her mother, an alcoholic, used to regularly beat her up. "She said that tired of her mother's beatings, her elder sister had run away from home," sources said.

"We have told her that her mother is in Goa, but she has not even once asked to meet her mother, cutting her completely out of her life. She repeatedly tells us that her mother and grandparents are the cause of her misery as they took money and put her as domestic work," added Audrey Pinto, director of SCAN, an NGO, who has been with the girl since the day she was rescued.

Though it's been almost five days since the mother has returned to Goa, she has not made any effort to meet her daughter.

Hospital sources said that when the minor's grandfather met her in the hospital after consenting to a medical examination by a panel of doctors, the girl accused him of ruining her life.

"When the grandfather suggested that once she is cured, they would send her back to Gadak, she got upset and accused them of being responsible for her condition. She said that she doesn't want to go with them," said sources.

Meanwhile, the ossification test to determine the minor's age will be conducted at GMC on Monday. Police had requested an ossification test on Saturday, as the minor doesn't possess a birth certificate or any other certificate to affirm her date of birth.

3 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Sunday, August 02, 2009

NGO objects to strangers visiting tortured girl in GMC

NGO objects to strangers visiting tortured girl in GMC
TNN

PANAJI: Stating that the 10-year-old tortured girl, who was working as a maid at Porvorim, is not a show piece', an NGO in Goa has strongly
objected to unknown people visiting the child and asking her to lift her skirt to see the wounds on her body. The NGO has also said that visitors were asking the minor, who is admitted to Goa medical college and hospital with burn injuries, about her past.

Stating that this is proving to be embarrassing for the minor, Audrey Pinto, director of NGO SCAN, who is the complainant in the child abuse case, in a letter to SP (North) said people asked the child to show them her wounds and the child is embarrassed every time she is asked to lift up her dress. The letter was sent on Friday.

"Please look into the matter as this is invading the child's privacy and confidentiality leading to violation of the principal of Goa Children's Act 2000", the letter, which has been written in the best interest of the child' notes.

Citing an incident that happened on Friday, Pinto wrote, "This afternoon 5 persons came to meet the child. They said they had taken permission from the Porvorim police. On inquiring with the constable on duty she said that they were given permission to see the child but could not ask any questions. She said the officer told her it would be ok as she was a victim and not the accused. These persons asked the child to show them the wounds".

When contacted, SP (north) Bosco George said, "We have taken serious note of the matter and given strict instructions to the staff deployed at GMC that no visitor should be allowed to meet the child until there is written clearance from the investigating officer."

The NGO, which in its police complaint last week had said that the three accused -- Audumber (Shubham) Pednekar, Minaxi and his sister-in-law Tina -- had allegedly with a common intention assaulted the minor girl with cable wire and also burned her with a hot steel frying pan on her thighs and back resulting in injuries, had requested the police to stop persons from visiting the victim. Policemen were also placed in GMC with her 24 X7.

However, on interacting with the child, the NGO found that several people had visited her and she was made to show the wound on her thighs to them.

The NGO has also objected to people bringing food for the minor in the hospital stating that "it might be dangerous for her if no proper monitoring is done".

2 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Denied bail, child maid's tormentors go into hiding

Denied bail, child maid's tormentors go into hiding
TNN

PANAJI: Cancelling the conditional bail granted earlier, president of the children’s court B P Deshpande, on Saturday directed Audumber Pendnekar to immediately surrender before the Porvorim police in connection with the alleged torture of a 10-year-old domestic help employed at his residence.

The court also rejected the separate anticipatory bail applications filed by Pednekar’s wife Minaxi and their relative Rekha Waghela. The trio, however, are absconding, despite Pednekar being required to be present at the police station every morning, said police sources. Cancelling Pednekar’s bail, the court observed that when the conditional bail was granted on July 27, the nature of the child’s injuries were not described in the hurt certificate.

Referring to the record submitted subsequently by the prosecution, the judge noted: "In all, there are 23 burn injuries which are found on various parts of the body and mainly near the stomach and on the thighs and also there is disfigurement of the face."

The court observed that the prosecution, on the basis of the opinion of the medical board, victim’s and other witnesses’ statements, had brought on record that a very serious offence had been committed on the 10-year-old child.

It further took into consideration the prosecution’s claim that the victim was unable to walk and sit properly due to the burn injuries and that three weeks were required for (her) recovery.

2 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Tamba effect: Govt promises funds to fight swine flu

Tamba effect: Govt promises funds to fight swine flu
TNN

PANAJI: Even as one more case of swine flu was confirmed on Saturday, bringing Goa’s tally of affected persons to seven, the government in an
apparent damage-control move decided to release the funds for the control of the disease.

A day after the state nodal officer for swine flu, Dr Rajendra Tamba, said he had no funds to carry out any activity related to the disease, chief secretary Sanjiv Srivastava said, "By Monday we will sort out the problem and the projected funds for swine flu control in Goa will be provided. We will see that such public health issues are not hampered in future."

Earlier in the day, chief minister Digambar Kamat said that "adequate funds were being released for the swine flu programme".

On Friday, Dr Tamba had issued a statement through the director of information appealing to the people not to contact him for information on swine flu since he had no funds to carry out any activity related to the disease. Government sources, however, said that the problem arose not due to lack of funds but due to "lack of coordination" between health department officials.

Meanwhile, a 26-year-old man who arrived in Goa on July 28 from the US via Hong Kong and was quarantined at GMC has tested positive for swine flu.

2 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition

Saturday, August 01, 2009

Do her pictures tell a story?



Do her pictures tell a story?
Preetu Nair, TNN


Photo courtesy: Rajtilak Naik

Panaji: We have seen only those scars on her skin,but there might be others deep down, inflicted by pain much more acute.

As she recovers from the torture allegedly inflicted by her employers , the child maid has for the first time in her life laid her hands on books and crayons. Cocooned inside a GMC ward , away from the cruel world she has so far experienced, the ten year old is learning the English alphabet, tutored by the policemen guarding her.

And she is drawing pictures. Neat, bright and colourful pictures. But amidst all the vibrancy might be lurking her worst demon-loneliness.

Most of her pictures are of her are of her house in Gadak, Hubli , surrounded by green fields and a girl standing alone. The minor says she is the girl in her sketches . In some sketches, along with her own name she has written the word 'Audrey' . Audrey Pinto is director of SCAN , an NGO, and has been with the girl since the day she was rescued.

Drawings can be used as a way of understanding more about what a child has gone through, how they view their past, present and future, says psychologists.

"Children express their needs and environment through the pictures they draw. From the pictures she had drawn it appears that she feels lonely. Perhaps after what she has gone through he family probably has no role to play in her environment as she cannot identify with them," said clinical psychologist Dr Mita Majumdar. However, she added that these are presumptions and one can arrive at a final decision only after interacting with the child and seeing her pictures.

Incidentally, the minor doesn't talk much about her family. "She doesn't talk about her mother or siblings. She told us very clearly that she doesn't want to go with her grandparents and mother. She told us that she wants to study," said Goa State Commission for Protection of Child Rights (GSCPCR) member Ezilda Sapeco.

August 1, The Times of India, Goa edition

"I couldn't believe it was the same girl' says man who found the minor

"I couldn't believe it was the same girl' says man who found the minor
Preetu Nair , TNN

PANAJI: When he offered some eatables to a little girl standing outside his shop last Saturday, Umesh Dhavaskar, 49, did not realize he had known
her before or that he was going to be instrumental in saving the girl from an unimaginable horror.

"I just couldn't believe this was the same girl I had known for the last three years. The girl I had known was pretty and chirpy, the one I was seeing now, after a gap of almost six months was sad, thin and without the charm she had," says Dhavaskar, who runs a modest restaurant in Mapusa near the bus stand.

"Last Saturday at about 9 am I saw a small girl standing outside my shop. I thought she was waiting for someone. An hour later, I noticed her again. When I approached her and asked her if she was waiting for someone, she got emotional and said, I am hungry'," recalls Dhavaskar, who then offered her some snacks.

While the girl was eating, an elderly motorcycle pilot Datta Salgaonkar walked into the restaurant and recognised her. "When he told me that this was the same girl who would walk into my restaurant often with her mother, smiling, cheerful and full of life, I was shocked. She looked so different. The girl I knew had thick hair, beautiful features and was healthy. But the girl who sat in front of me was lean, with very short hair and appeared disillusioned with life," said Dhavaskar.

Dhavaskar had no knowledge of the girl's injuries at that time. It was only after the girl spilled her tale of woes to Salgaonkar and his wife that this came to be known. "I was shocked when I heard her story and saw her wounds. I have three young daughters. I just couldn't believe that a human being can treat a child like this," he said.

He added, "I called the police and said, Here is a girl in dismay standing in my shop. If you can help, do help her'." The Mapusa police came within 15 minutes to help the minor, he added.

People in the vicinity knew the child and her mother, who worked as a daily wage worker at construction sites. They allege that the mother was an alcoholic and would often beat the minor. Incidentally, the minor's mother, who couldn't be traced, returned to Goa on Thursday and the police recorded her statement on Thursday.

"The mother said she had come from Gadak to meet her daughter as she was in the hospital. She also said that she was aware that her daughter was working as a domestic help at the Pednekar residence at Porvorim," says Dhavaskar.

1 August 2009, The Times of India, Goa edition